Have You Ever Added Up Every Processing Fee for an Entire Year?
Most business owners know they pay something for credit card processing. Fewer have ever sat down with twelve months of statements and added up every line: the percentage-based fees, the per-transaction charges, the monthly account fee, the PCI-related fee, the equipment or software charge, and any additional network or assessment fees that appear in small print near the bottom.
When merchants do that math, the total is often larger than expected. That number — your total annual processing cost — is the starting point for any honest conversation about whether a different pricing structure might improve your margins.
This post explains how to calculate your actual processing cost, what the EDGE dual-pricing program is, and how to think about whether it might fit your business. All savings examples in this post are hypothetical illustrations. Actual results depend on your sales mix, average ticket, card types accepted, debit usage, processor pricing, customer behavior, and program configuration.
---
Section 1: What Processing Really Costs
A typical merchant's monthly statement includes several cost categories that are easy to overlook individually but significant in total.
Percentage-based processing fees are the most visible. These are charged as a percentage of each card transaction. The rate varies based on the card type (rewards cards cost more than basic debit), how the card was presented (in-person chip transactions cost less than keyed-in or online transactions), and your pricing model.
Per-transaction fees are flat charges applied to each individual transaction, regardless of the amount. A $0.10 per-transaction fee on 500 monthly transactions adds $50 to your monthly cost — $600 per year — before you count the percentage fees.
Monthly account and statement fees are charged by many processors simply for maintaining the account. These range from a few dollars to $30 or more per month.
PCI-related fees cover the cost of maintaining Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard compliance. Some processors charge a flat annual fee; others charge monthly. Some charge a separate non-compliance penalty if you have not completed your annual questionnaire.
Equipment or software charges may include terminal rental, POS software subscriptions, gateway fees for online payments, and any app or integration charges.
Chargeback fees are assessed when a customer disputes a transaction. Even if you win the dispute, many processors still charge a fee for the review process.
Network and assessment fees are pass-through charges from Visa, Mastercard, Discover, and American Express. These are non-negotiable and appear on most detailed statements.
Illustrative Annual Cost Example
To illustrate how these add up, consider a hypothetical retail business with $400,000 in annual card volume:
| Cost Component | Hypothetical Monthly | Hypothetical Annual |
|---|---|---|
| Percentage-based fees (2.5% effective rate) | $833 | $10,000 |
| Per-transaction fees ($0.10 × 600 transactions) | $60 | $720 |
| Monthly account fee | $15 | $180 |
| PCI compliance fee | $10 | $120 |
| Equipment/software | $30 | $360 |
| Chargeback fees (2 per month average) | $30 | $360 |
| Estimated Total | $978 | $11,740 |
This is a hypothetical illustration only. Your actual costs depend on your processor, pricing model, card mix, and transaction volume. Request a free statement review to see your real numbers.
---
Section 2: What the EDGE Program Is
The EDGE Program is Custom Payments' dual-pricing solution. It is designed to allow businesses to offer two prices: a standard price for customers who pay with cash, and a slightly higher price for customers who pay by credit or debit card. The difference between the two prices is intended to offset the cost of card acceptance.
How prices are displayed: Under a properly configured dual-pricing program, both the cash price and the card price are displayed to the customer before the transaction. The customer chooses how to pay. This transparency is a key element of compliance.
How EDGE differs from a conventional surcharge: A credit card surcharge adds a fee on top of a posted price at the time of payment. A dual-pricing or cash-discount program posts both prices upfront. The distinction matters because card networks and state laws treat these structures differently. EDGE is designed as a dual-pricing program, not a surcharge.
Why configuration and disclosure matter: The compliance requirements for dual-pricing programs include signage at the point of entry and point of sale, receipt language, and in some cases specific POS programming. Requirements can vary by state, card type, card network, and transaction type. A merchant should receive a compliance review before launching any dual-pricing program.
What EDGE does not do: No dual-pricing program eliminates 100% of all processing-related costs in every scenario. Debit card transactions, online transactions, and certain card types may be treated differently depending on program configuration. Ask Custom Payments to confirm the specific structure and what it covers before making any assumptions about your net cost.
---
Section 3: Hypothetical Savings Examples
The following examples are clearly labeled as hypothetical illustrations. They are not guarantees, projections, or representations of results achieved by any specific business. Actual results depend on sales mix, average ticket, card types, debit usage, processor pricing, customer behavior, and program configuration.
Example 1: Private Club or Fraternal Organization
| Factor | Hypothetical Value |
|---|---|
| Annual card sales | $180,000 |
| Estimated card percentage | 70% of total sales |
| Estimated effective processing cost | 2.8% |
| Estimated current annual processing cost | ~$5,040 |
| Assumed customer payment shift to cash | 25% |
| Estimated annual cost after pricing change | ~$3,780 |
| Hypothetical annual difference | ~$1,260 |
Example 2: Liquor Store
| Factor | Hypothetical Value |
|---|---|
| Annual card sales | $600,000 |
| Estimated card percentage | 80% of total sales |
| Estimated effective processing cost | 2.6% |
| Estimated current annual processing cost | ~$15,600 |
| Assumed customer payment shift to cash | 20% |
| Estimated annual cost after pricing change | ~$12,480 |
| Hypothetical annual difference | ~$3,120 |
Example 3: Hair Salon or Spa
| Factor | Hypothetical Value |
|---|---|
| Annual card sales | $220,000 |
| Estimated card percentage | 85% of total sales |
| Estimated effective processing cost | 2.9% |
| Estimated current annual processing cost | ~$6,380 |
| Assumed customer payment shift to cash | 15% |
| Estimated annual cost after pricing change | ~$5,423 |
| Hypothetical annual difference | ~$957 |
Example 4: Bar or Restaurant
| Factor | Hypothetical Value |
|---|---|
| Annual card sales | $500,000 |
| Estimated card percentage | 75% of total sales |
| Estimated effective processing cost | 3.1% |
| Estimated current annual processing cost | ~$15,500 |
| Assumed customer payment shift to cash | 20% |
| Estimated annual cost after pricing change | ~$12,400 |
| Hypothetical annual difference | ~$3,100 |
Actual results depend on sales mix, average ticket, card types, debit usage, processor pricing, customer behavior, and program configuration.
---
Section 4: How to Estimate Your Own Savings
You do not need a consultant to start this process. Here is a five-step method you can complete with your own statements.
Step 1: Gather three recent processing statements. Use the last three full months. If your business is seasonal, choose months that represent your typical volume.
Step 2: Calculate total card volume. Add up the total dollar amount of card transactions for each month, then calculate the three-month total.
Step 3: Add all processing and account fees. Include every fee on the statement: percentage fees, per-transaction fees, monthly fees, PCI fees, equipment charges, and any other line items.
Step 4: Determine your current effective rate. Use this formula:
> Effective rate = total processing-related fees ÷ total card volume × 100
For example: $3,200 in fees ÷ $120,000 in volume × 100 = 2.67% effective rate
Step 5: Compare your current model with a compliant EDGE proposal. Request a free statement review from Custom Payments. We will calculate your current effective rate and show you what a compliant dual-pricing program would look like for your specific business — including any costs that would remain.
---
Section 5: Questions to Ask Before Switching
Before changing your pricing structure, ask your processor or consultant these questions:
- Customer communication: How will you explain the pricing change to customers? What signage is required?
- POS compatibility: Does your current system support dual-pricing display? Will it require reprogramming or replacement?
- Debit card treatment: How are debit card transactions handled under this program?
- Refunds: How are refunds processed when a customer paid the card price?
- Tips: How are tips calculated — on the pre-tip amount or the total?
- Online transactions: Does the program apply to online or phone orders?
- Existing contracts: Are you in a contract with your current processor? What are the termination terms?
- Equipment: Will you need new terminals? Who owns the equipment?
- Settlement timing: When will funds be deposited to your account?
- Staff training: Who provides training, and what does it cover?
---
Section 6: Benefits Beyond Rate Reduction
A dual-pricing program is not only about reducing your processing cost. There are other potential benefits worth considering.
Pricing transparency: When both prices are displayed, customers understand exactly what they are paying for. There are no hidden fees and no surprises on their card statement.
Better understanding of your own costs: Going through the statement review process forces a clear look at what processing actually costs — information many business owners have never had.
Staff training: Implementing a new pricing structure requires training your team. That process often improves overall payment handling and reduces errors.
Local support: Working with a local provider means you have a real person to call when questions come up — not a call center.
Customer choice: Customers retain the ability to choose how they pay. Some will choose cash; others will pay the card price. The program does not eliminate card acceptance.
Reduced dependence on rate-only comparisons: Once you understand your effective rate, you are better equipped to evaluate any processor's proposal — not just on the headline rate, but on the total cost.
---
Is the EDGE Program Right for Your Business?
The honest answer is: it depends. The EDGE Program may be a strong fit for businesses with high average tickets, cash-friendly customer bases, or thin margins where processing costs have a meaningful impact. It may be less suitable for businesses where customers strongly prefer card payment, where online transactions represent a large share of volume, or where the compliance requirements would be difficult to implement.
The best way to find out is to review your actual statements with someone who can show you the real numbers — not a hypothetical sales pitch.
Request a free processing-statement review from Custom Payments. Robert Staschak will review your statements, calculate your current effective rate, and explain what a compliant EDGE program would look like for your specific business. There is no obligation and no pressure.
Call (484) 393-1576 or visit custompayments.biz to schedule your review.
Disclaimer: All savings examples in this post are hypothetical illustrations only. Actual results depend on your sales mix, average ticket, card types accepted, debit usage, processor pricing, customer behavior, and program configuration. The EDGE Program must be configured in compliance with applicable state laws and card-network rules. Custom Payments does not guarantee any specific savings outcome. Ask Custom Payments to confirm the exact program structure before implementation.